When an American couple from Texas recently approached Bettianne Hedges with ambitions of purchasing a home in Stratford, Ontario, they were not searching for the typical, remote Canadian cottage country experience. Instead, they envisioned a vibrant community gathering place where their geographically scattered family could comfortably convene, take in a world-class theatrical performance at the renowned Stratford Festival, and fully immerse themselves in the city’s rich cultural offerings. However, their aspirations ran directly into a formidable regulatory barrier: Canada’s ongoing federal ban on foreign home buyers.
Hedges, an experienced broker with Sotheby’s International Realty Canada, had previously been optimistic that the contentious restrictions would quietly expire as originally scheduled on January 1, 2027. Instead, the federal government has chosen a different path. In the federal budget released last Thursday, the administration proposed extending the existing restrictions on foreign purchases of residential properties for an additional two years, moving the expiration date to January 1, 2029. At the same time, the newly outlined policy introduces a targeted exemption, permitting international buyers to purchase newly constructed, pre-built residential homes. According to the federal government, this nuanced approach is designed to safeguard existing housing inventory for domestic buyers while simultaneously injecting much-needed foreign investment and capital directly into new residential construction projects.
Yet, as the policy details are digested across the country, economists, housing analysts, and real estate professionals are openly questioning whether this newly carved-out exemption will generate sufficient demand to meaningfully move the needle on Canada’s broader, struggling housing market.
‘Marginal at best’
Benjamin Tal, deputy chief economist at CIBC World Markets Inc., points out that the original foreign buyer ban, which was initially introduced in January 2023, wielded a relatively limited macroeconomic impact on a national scale.
“From a macro perspective, the impact was marginal; foreign buyers accounted for about five per cent of transactions. But it was more significant in specific centres such as Vancouver,” Tal explained in an email interview.
While Tal supports the government’s newly proposed distinction between existing housing inventory and newly built construction, he does not anticipate that the change will trigger a major market shift or a sudden buying frenzy.
“It is reasonable to exempt newly built homes; the impact will be marginal at best,” he states. When asked whether the exemption could successfully encourage real estate developers to launch stalled projects or help clear out existing unsold inventory, Tal remains cautious. “I doubt it will be big enough to trigger a big surge, but it would help at the margin.”
Furthermore, Tal expects minimal upward pressure on home prices across the country as a result of the policy shift. While supply and demand dynamics in cities like Vancouver might experience a slightly more noticeable reaction, he notes that the sheer volume of currently unsold condominium inventory in the Pacific coastal city means any resulting impact on market prices will be exceedingly slow to materialize.
Mitch Strohminger, director of market analytics at CoStar Group, shares a similar assessment, suggesting that the federal government is strategically attempting to direct foreign investment toward the upper tier of the housing market—a segment where domestic developers have historically struggled to secure reliable buyers.
“The upper tier has been under pressure because units built were priced beyond the reach of many domestic buyers and renters due to rapidly rising construction costs,” Strohminger noted. By maintaining strict limitations on existing residential properties, he suggests the federal government intends to limit direct competition in the more affordable segments of the market where local buyers are most vulnerable.
Provincial taxes remain a barrier
Despite the federal government’s attempt to stimulate new construction through the foreign buyer exemption, industry leaders in high-cost metropolitan markets argue that existing provincial and municipal tax structures will continue to deter international capital.
In Vancouver, Dan Scarrow of Macdonald Realty remains deeply skeptical that the federal exemption alone will successfully revive foreign investment without concurrent, sweeping changes to regional tax policies.
“As long as that 20 per cent foreign buyer tax remains on there, the three per cent spec and vacancy tax, the empty homes tax in Vancouver, the flipping tax here in B.C., it’s not going to move the needle,” Scarrow asserts.
Scarrow, whose prominent brokerage operated a dedicated office in Shanghai from approximately 2014 to 2021, recalls that international buyer activity in British Columbia cooled down considerably as cumulative taxes and regulatory restrictions were progressively introduced by various levels of government. In his estimation, the provincial foreign buyer tax would likely need to be reduced to approximately 10 per cent, alongside meaningful modifications to vacancy-related municipal taxes, before any significant wave of international demand could realistically return to the region.
“I don’t think either of those things are going to happen,” he remarks candidly.
Even during the historical peak of foreign buying activity in Western Canada, Scarrow estimates that international purchasers accounted for only a minor fraction of Vancouver’s overall presale condominium market. Nevertheless, he acknowledges that a modest influx of additional buyers could help some struggling developers successfully meet the strict presale financing thresholds required by institutional lenders to break ground on new residential projects.
“That could be a marginal difference for some projects that need to push their pre-sale requirements over a certain line,” Scarrow notes. For him, however, the overarching and more pressing issue is whether Canada can collectively attract enough investment capital to support essential new construction. “The least livable home is a home that never gets built,” he emphasizes.
A different kind of cottage country
Far away from the high-density condominium towers of Vancouver, Bettianne Hedges is observing the impacts of the federal policy through an entirely different lens in the historic town of Stratford. She believes that the proposed exemption overlooks smaller towns, cultural hubs, and secondary cities where international buyers have historically sought second homes outside of the traditional, rural cottage communities typically associated with Canadian leisure real estate.
Hedges points out that American second-home owners have long contributed meaningfully to the local cultural economy of Stratford and similar heritage destinations. In some cases, these international buyers have purchased character properties equipped with secondary suites that can accommodate seasonal theatre workers, artists, and festival personnel. Furthermore, she questions whether blanket restrictions aimed at keeping these specific buyers out of the market have accomplished their stated goal of genuinely improving local housing affordability for everyday residents.
“I don’t think it’s had any impact at all,” Hedges says bluntly.
Instead, she argues that the federal restrictions have inadvertently reduced opportunities for consumer spending within the local arts, hospitality, and cultural sectors. While international visitors may still occasionally travel to the city for short-term getaways, she notes that an extended seasonal presence would have allowed significantly more discretionary financial capital to flow directly into the community.
For Hedges, the fundamental disconnect lies in the fact that a broad, national policy designed around overarching macroeconomic housing conditions does not accurately reflect the unique economic realities, needs, and opportunities of individual communities across Ontario and the rest of the country.
“It’s underestimating what our Canadian and even Ontario cities have to offer to an international buyer,” she concludes.