If Canada had allowed medical assistance in dying (MAID) for mental health issues two decades ago, Alexandra Shimo would not be here today. Twenty-one years ago, at the age of 26, she had just made the bold move from London, U.K., to Toronto, chasing romance and harboring high hopes of breaking into the broadcasting industry. Instead, she found herself paralyzed by extreme, unmanaged anxiety that made holding down steady employment an insurmountable challenge.
In a system stretched to its breaking point, Shimo’s experience quickly became a harrowing trial-and-error cycle. Each month or two, she would return to her family doctor to experiment with a rotating door of pharmaceutical combinations: a higher dose of Olanzapine, a reduction in Lorazepam, or the addition of Effexor. Alarmingly, the latter two medications have frequently been linked in clinical contexts to an increased risk of suicidal ideation.
When she asked for specialized intervention, her physician placed her on a waitlist for a psychiatrist. The estimated wait time? Roughly five years. Because her severe anxiety had already compromised her ability to maintain a steady job, private psychotherapy was entirely out of financial reach. Cut off from meaningful psychological support, her mental state began a rapid downward spiral. Eventually, she became consumed by obsessive thoughts about how she might take her own life.
Shimo’s story is far from an isolated incident. Across Canada, pharmaceuticals are rarely considered the gold standard of care for complex mental health patients, yet they remain the default—and often the only—treatment dispensed by family doctors. For the vast majority of Canadians seeking help for psychological distress, general practitioners serve as the sole source of medical support. This structural bottleneck frequently leaves vulnerable patients without the comprehensive care they actually need, which clinical guidelines almost universally dictate should involve psychotherapy and specialized behavioral interventions. In many cases, unmonitored medication management can even exacerbate a patient’s underlying condition.
"You are given drugs without the necessary supervision, and it’s terrifying," says Michael Schellenberg, a book editor based in Winnipeg who lives with bipolar I disorder. Describing the precarious nature of primary care psychiatry, Schellenberg captures the profound vulnerability felt by thousands of patients: "You feel that the doctors are playing spin the wheel of fortune with your life."
Whether harrowing personal accounts like those of Shimo and Schellenberg represent a systemic, nationwide pattern is precisely the question the federal government set out to answer in recent years. Seeking a policy solution to the complex intersections of chronic mental illness, suffering, and end-of-life care, Ottawa commissioned several independent reports to determine whether MAID framework legislation should be formally expanded to include individuals whose sole underlying condition is a mental illness.
The findings of the government’s most recent comprehensive report, published in June, were stark and deeply damning. The investigation revealed that access to necessary medical and psychological services across Canada is heavily dictated by social determinants of health, including persistent poverty, disability, social isolation, and inadequate housing. Furthermore, the report underscored a glaring supply-and-demand mismatch: the societal demand for accessible mental health care continues to compound year over year, while public service capacity remains largely stagnant.

Data from the Canadian Institute for Health Information highlights the staggering scale of the deficit. In 2025, the institute reported that 41 percent of Canadian adults suffering from a mental illness stated their healthcare needs were either entirely unmet or only partially addressed. For young adults, the situation was markedly worse, with a staggering 92 percent claiming they received little to no meaningful help for their mental health struggles.
Facing mounting pressure, ethical concerns, and systemic readiness evaluations, the federal government ultimately suspended its controversial plans to expand MAID eligibility for mental health conditions in early October. However, a glaring omission shadowed the announcement: the government’s decision was unaccompanied by any concrete, adequately funded strategy to dramatically enhance access to life-saving, preventative mental health care.
When questioned about this gap by journalists and advocacy groups, representatives from Health Canada pointed toward existing provisions and broad policy commitments. "The Government of Canada remains committed to taking a comprehensive approach to improve access to mental health services and supports," the agency stated in an official response, adding that this ongoing initiative involves "working with provinces and territories to improve access to mental health services as part of integrated person-centred care."
For those currently navigating the system without a safety net, such broad policy assurances offer little practical comfort. Schellenberg notes that he has found it virtually impossible to secure a permanent psychiatrist in Manitoba, having routinely encountered estimated waitlists stretching outward to five years.
"As a mental health patient, you are almost entirely on your own," Schellenberg reflects, summing up the isolation felt by many patients. "So much of the necessary help is out of reach for ordinary Canadians."
For Shimo, the passage of more than two decades has brought little structural improvement. To this day, she has still not been able to secure a reliable, long-term psychiatrist to oversee and manage her care. The absence of continuous, specialized support has yielded severe, multifarious consequences over the years, including eight separate psychiatric hospitalizations, four job losses, and periods of immense domestic strain during which her spouse suffered from depression brought on by the unrelenting household upheaval.
Today, Shimo notes that she remains anchored to the living side of the life-death divide primarily by the strength of a loving family. Yet, the ongoing chaos and systemic neglect generated by the chronic lack of accessible mental health resources continue to test the limits of that support system on a regular basis.